home   message   history



typicrobots replied to your post: i’m gonna complain about things and you’re gonna…

Can you give me a succinct summary of wtf is going on w LBD bc I only watch the Darcy eps bc everything about LBD seems a mess, even the Darcy eps.

oh my god, hold on to your butt, ‘cause HERE WE GO (also this isn’t going to be succinct):

  • #1 thing you need to know is that one of the writers on staff, rachel kiley, is not someone who should be a writer on staff. she aggressively hates on basically every character not intimately connected with her pet (lydia) and most of the characters who are connected with her, too. except for wickham, noted dreamboat & celebrated great guy (“that makes sense” —jane austen)
  • there’s an ancillary lydia vlog that is frankly unnecessary esp the third series of lydia vlogs which are just honest to god like six episodes of lydia trapped in a horrible relationship with wickham who is pretty clearly emotionally manipulating and abusing her.
  • we go to rk and the actress who plays lydia: “wickham is so sexy/great/romantic/perfect for lydia!!!” there you have it, folks: bullshit. the official lbd twitter account retweets ~lyckham~ tweets.
  • meanwhile wickham is isolating lydia from her friends and family, castigating her while simultaneously presenting himself as the only one who understands/loves her, and clearly using her as a means to prop himself up while also getting ~revenge~ on lizzie & darcy. aka abusing her. BUT MAYBE HE’S SAD, YOU GUYS!!!
  • an illuminating digression: this show has a v gross attitude towards female sexuality. lydia is “bad” because she’s sexually active/talks about sex (then: rachel kiley argues that the show isn’t slut-shaming lydia because lydia isn’t even sexually active omg she’s totally not a whore), and jane is “good” because her relationship with bing is thoroughly chaste.
  • lydia is shamed by the narrative for “allowing” herself to be abused ( L M A O ) and for having participated in the making of the sex tape, while it also argues that she’s a GOOD GIRL (read: not sexually active! she doesn’t have sex! really! at all! because goodness is intrinsically tied to sexual activity! she’s not a slut omg). she is thus, in the narrative’s execution, both a martyr and a bad girl who got what was coming to her. neither does justice to what could have been lydia’s character, and this presentation is grossly simplistic and, BIZARRELY, even less progressive than the source material from 1813. at least lydia had agency in pride & prejudice; in lbd, she’s a victim without power or voice.

and all of that was a lot of words for sure BUT WAIT, THERE’S MORE:

rachel kiley hates criticism. she really, REALLY hates criticism. she hates it so much that she wrote an EIGHT MINUTE EPISODE (today’s) in which lydia basically speaks ON BEHALF OF RACHEL KILEY about how fandom is MEAN and SEXIST and HOW DARE THEY CRITICIZE RACHEL KILEY i mean LYDIA and THIS IS ALL YOOOOUR FAUUUULT, YOOOOU DID THIIIIIIIS

and lydia is also crying about how she’s responsible for the existence of the sex tape because she let it happennnnn, and lizzie has been inexplicably uploading all this extremely private, personal shit to the internet, but now lizzie sees, she sees how wrong she was to ever criticize lydia, for is it not lizzie’s fault too for pushing lydia away, and isn’t it also jane’s fault for not being there, and it’s everyone’s fault BUT ESPECIALLY THE WOMEN’S except… for wickham’s…

meanwhile darcy has completely forgotten he is so rich he can literally make and wear underwear out of $100 bills and then set them on fire at the end of each day, and thus he is uniquely capable of a) hiring private detectives to find wickham and b) hiring lawyers who can shut wickham down, you know, IF darcy bothered to ask lydia what SHE wants, which he hasn’t

lbd: feminism

or, TO REALLY BE SUCCINCT: lbd isn’t a ROMANCE, it’s about SLUT-SHAMING. i mean, sisters. no, wait, yeah, slut-shaming

PERFECT commentary, omg.

this show has jumped the shark so bad, you guys - a terribly annoying, slut-shaming shark who roams the Sea of Bad Decisions & Shitty Worldbuilding - and I’m honestly not sure if I’ve ever been so quickly & thoroughly disengaged with a fictional narrative, and the gross sexual politics are only half of it.

dear LBD: Lizzie-as-videoblogger is the central conceit of this adaptation. the limitations of the form can hardly have surprised you, so why the fuck are SO MANY of your recent writing choices falling apart because your viewers (who, btw, have been able to suspend disbelief & enjoy the form thus far) are completely unable to reconcile your characters’ approach to things like:

  • methods of modern communication (see: NO ONE being aware of Lydia’s videos with Wickham, see also: Charlotte’s magical inability to get in touch with Lizzie)
  • hushing up something on the Internet (protip: if you don’t want people to find out about your sister’s sextape, DON’T BLOG ABOUT IT TO HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE)
  • retaining a competent legal team (see: William Darcy, fabulously wealthy & successful CEO of a new media company in Silicon Valley, who nevertheless has no idea how to engage attorneys specializing in Internet law)
  • launching & marketing a new app (protip: don’t use the app demo to have incredibly painful, public breakdowns & reveal all your plans to your nemesis)

like, even aside from the really gross sexual politics, NONE OF THIS MAKES ANY SENSE. AT ALL.

I can’t watch anymore. I’ll tune back in when people start making out on screen, but I no longer care about the bits in between, because there is literally no way to retcon this mess into something coherent and logical.

1 year ago with 290 notes    via / root

  1. aelithian reblogged this from stelmarias
  2. kirensauce reblogged this from genebeanbelcher
  3. arleehayes reblogged this from daceymormont
  4. ofunicorndust reblogged this from growingintheweeds
  5. mareemallory reblogged this from dicktective-archive
  6. nothingsensible-archive reblogged this from windfalling
  7. driftinginnova reblogged this from vespermartini
  8. stoictomato reblogged this from nicodreams
  9. isaia said: I am listening to creepy horror music, it is swelling as I read this entry. Oddly fitting. :((
  10. forgettingstegosaurus reblogged this from vespermartini
  11. fangirlsontop reblogged this from vespermartini
  12. noonaifyounasty said: jesus h christ what a clusterfuck. this thing started out so charming and then just flew right off the train track and into a ravine (at which point it exploded in flames) what a waste -_-
  13. calvinball-rulemaker reblogged this from everythingsbetterwithbisexuals
  14. mbelle51 reblogged this from captaindove
  15. katbamkapow reblogged this from dinkerton
  16. songsofthedoctordonna reblogged this from windfalling
  17. windfalling reblogged this from hariboo
  18. captaindove reblogged this from hariboo
  19. zaytans reblogged this from vespermartini
  20. vespermartini reblogged this from hariboo